Operation Good Cause 2019 is a fundraiser raffle of a 28mm WW2 US army benefiting the ICRC.

Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Review. Show all posts

Rules Review - What A Tanker!

What a Tanker! is one of the newest releases by Too Fat Lardies, and they were so kind to donate one of the books (and a matching token set) to our project!


What a Tanker! is designed as a multi-player tank duel game. It is recommended that each player fields a single vehicle, but you want at least 2 vehicles per team, and in my experience, each player can easily control up to 3 vehicles. There is a point system that gives you an idea which vehicles are roughly equals, and it works very nicely. Of course there are some very powerful vehicles like the Jagdtiger, which will give your opponent some head ache if he invested in a more balanced force, but these kind of matches should be very rare.

The game also features rules for campaign play, in which your crews earn experience, get promoted to more expensive vehicles and gain special abilities. Five kills give you ace status, and you’ll gain a special ability or upgrade to the next tier of tanks.
Each tanks has two main attributes, Strike and Armor. Strike is the strength of your gun, and armor is, well, the strength of your armor. Besides that, there are some special rules like Fast (more opportunities to move), Rapid Fire (only needs to reload once per turn) or Iron Fist (better chance to deal permanent damage).

Each player uses a dashboard for each vehicle to keep track of its status. 


The activation is kind of similar to Chain of Command. Each tank has 5 command dice whih are rolled at the start of each activation. Different results allow different actions: 1 is movement, 2 is target acquisition, 3 is aim, 4 is shoot, 5 is reload and 6 is a wild card that can be used as any other dice, to give you an advantage for initiative next round or to modify to hit numbers. Yes, you need to go through a lot of steps to shoot at your enemy. And yes, you may be all set up and ready but can’t get the “4” that will actually allow you to deal out some pain. But in reality, these moments are rare, and they are what gives this game spice. You will be very often have those “stand up”-roll, when this one drive or shoot dice will make or break your gamble.

Once you are unleashing on an opponent’s tank, you roll 2D6 modified by movement and terrain to hit. After that, you roll your Strike dice and your opponent rolls his Armor dice. Depending on positions, you’ll need different results to score kits. For example, if you hit the front armor, you’ll need 5s for hits and 6s for critical hits, on the rear armor you’ll get hits for every die showing a 3 and criticals for every result of 4 or more. The target needs 5s or 6s for saves. Compare the results: More saves than hits means the shot didn’t do anything. An equal number of hits and saves means minor damage and the target falls back. If you score more hits than saves, you’ll do damage: temporary damage if you rolled more ordinary hits than criticals, and permanent damage when you rolled more critical than ordinary hits. If you have 3 more hits than the target has saves, the target is outright destroyed by your shot. Temporary and permanent damage costs you command dice, and permanent damage also affects your hull or turret.

If your tank is reduced to zero command dice, the crew will bail out and the vehicle is destroyed. Matches often develop into a game of cat and mouse when each side hopes for the right combination of dice to come up to support their fiendish plans, but it never gets dull.
This is What a Tanker! in a nutshell. It is a fast, fun game with a lot of randomness, but it rarely feels frustrating. Definitely on the “beer & pretzels” side of gaming, but still pleasantly sophisticated, and a great way to have some fun with a unique way to play.



And the winner of our raffle will not only get a copy of the rule book, but also a set of tokens for their dashboards!

Review - JTFM/Die Waffenkammer GMC CCKW 353 "Deuce and a half"

So, here it is, the last unit review for Operation Good Cause! JTFM/Die Waffenkammer did not just give us their Jumbo Sherman, but also another truck, more precisely a GMC CCKW 353 "Deuce and a half". Over half a million of these were built between 1941 and 1945 and they became a very common sight in Western Europe. It is also the base for the famous DUKW.

As always, JTFM kits come very safely packed:


The truck itself comes as a chassis, separate wheels and optional pieces like canvas covers, seating benches and machine gun. This allows a lot of easy customization. The canvas cover for the back can also easily be kept removable.


Although the chassis is one piece the details are top notch as usual for JTFM:


In addition to the amazing truck model you also get a driver, 5 passengers and a good mix of personal items to put on your vehicle.


Again, the quality and details on those miniatures is some of the best you will ever see in resin:


Assembly is very easy due to the limit number of parts and the great quality. Everything fits as it should, and using two-component resin it will stay together forever.

I decided to build the truck as a transport, so I put in the benches in the back. But then again, you just pop on the canvas and it is a supply truck.
I think eventually I'll have to put the driver in the cabin to be able to add the machine gun, but I'll keep the passengers separate so they can be used as crew for the jeeps.

I can just repeat what I always say: JTFM/Die Waffenkammer is my go-to source for high quality resin kits. Highly recommend!

Review - Butlers' Printed Models M8 Scott

Great Scott! Today we have a closer look at Butlers' Printed Models 75 mm Howitzer Motor Carriage M8.


The M8 Scott was a self-propelled howitzer based on the M5 Stuart light tank. It was used by Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadrons for close support against fortified positions and saw action in Italy, North-West Europe and the Pacific.
Although based on the Stuart it differs from it in many aspects. It uses a new, larger turret and the hull had no hatches for the driver and loader. Instead, all crew had to get in and out of the vehicle through the open-topped turret. It also lacked a hull-mounted machine gun, but had a .50 cal mounted on the back of the turret.

Butlers' Printed Models offers a M8 Scott in different scales, including 28mm and 1/48th. Here, we look at the 28mm version:


While the hull correctly shows the large vision flaps on the glacis and the additional periscopes on the top, it also has a hull MG modeled. I guess I will just remove it.

Overall, the print is okay. Yes, there are visible steps, but this is straight "out of box" and it will be easy to sand the larger areas down. Otherwise, proportions and details look fine.


In comparison to the Rubicon Models the M8 Scott is larger, but the dimensions are almost perfectly 1/56th scale. In reality, the M8 was slightly longer and taller than the M5 Stuart. So if at all, the Rubicon Models M5 is too high.


Overall, a nice model that doesn't require any assembly, but offers a good degree of details. The addition of the hull MG is a weird oversight, but that is easily corrected.

Review - Stoessi's Heroes Airborne Characters

We are very proud to count Stoessi's Heroes among our sponsors. They have an amazing range of miniatures based on real life characters from WW2, and they are doing an amazing job at capturing their essence.



The miniatures are packed in robust blister packs, and I say robust for a reason. Poor Dick Winters had an encounter with a 6 months old boxer mix and came out of it alright:


Although his blister got chewed up quite good, he himself didn't suffer any damage:


Every miniatures comes with a description of its real life equivalent.


So let's have a closer look at the other characters:

US Airborne Technician Fourth Grade Eugene Gilbert Roe
Sr.Roe was one of Easy Company’s medics and by the time they went into Carentan, Roe was already a seasoned veteran, able to patch and diagnose wounds in a methodical way.
Roe participated in Operation Market Garden and jumped into the Netherlands.
He also took part in the Battle of the Bulge at Bastogne. Allied supplies were low and Roe had to go from man to man to get more supplies. In the extreme cold weather, he had to tuck plasma bottles into his armpits to keep them from freezing.
US Airborne Lieutenant Colonel Robert George Cole
On June 11, 1944 LtCol. Robert Cole with the 101st Airborne Division, had the objective to take Carentan. The young commander called in a smoke barrage right in front of the German positions and ordered his men to fix bayonets and charge. Many Americans were killed as they assaulted, but more than 100 of Cole’s men managed to reach the German lines causing the defenders to flee. The attack would go down in history as “Cole’s Charge”. Cole won the Medal of Honor, but got killed in combat before the citation could be presented.
US Airborne Lieutenant Ronald C. Speirs
Lt. Speirs served in the 506th PIR, 101st Airborne. During the battle for Foy in Bastogne, a platoon had been ordered to go on a flanking mission. To countermand this order, Speirs ran through the town and German lines, linked up with the platoon and relayed the order. Having completed this, he then ran back through the German-occupied town.
“At first the Germans didn’t shoot at him. I think they couldn’t quite believe what they were seeing. But that wasn’t the really astounding thing. The astounding thing was that, after he hooked up with I Company, he came back.” – Carwood Lipton
US Airborne First Lieutenant Lynn “Buck” Compton
Lynn Davis “Buck” Compton was a commissioned officer with Easy Company, 2nd Battalion, 506th PIR, in the 101st Airborne Division.
During the company’s action at BrĂ©court Manor on D-Day, Compton and others, under the leadership of Lieutenant Richard Winters, assaulted a German battery of four 105 mm howitzers firing on Utah Beach, disabling the guns and routing the enemy.
Compton took one of the gun emplacements by himself and was awarded the Silver Star for his actions during the assault.
US Airborne Staff Sergeant “Wild Bill” Guarnere
William J. Guarnere was a US Army soldier who fought in WWII as a non-commissioned officer with Easy Company, 2nd Battalion, 506th Parachute Infantry Regiment, in the U.S. Army’s 101st Airborne Division.
The night before the invasion of Normandy, Guarnere found out his brother was killed at Monte Cassino, Italy. He made the parachute drop on D-day. After regrouping with his company, the unit encountered a German patrol and ambushed it, affording Guarnere his revenge for the loss of his brother at Monte Cassino.
The quality of the miniatures is flawless and I appreciate that they come without a base or gate. Poses are very life-like and all the details look right. They also mix very well with other ranges (like this partly painted Warlord Games Paratrooper):


Stoessi's Heroes has a wide range of miniatures, including all major powers and even some iconic movie characters. Definitely worth a look!

Review - Trenchworx M4A4 Sherman

Today we have a slightly different kind of review.
Trenchworx generously donated not one, but two of their wonderful M4A4 Shermans to our project.


Trenchworx manufactured excellent resin/metal hybrid kits. As you can see, the details are all you could hope for, and as far as I can tell the fit between metal and resin is very good.

And even better, I don't have to paint them! Mr. Justin from Secret Weapon Miniatures agreed to work his magic on them for us, and he also recorded most of it on youtube. Enjoy!


With these two new additions we are now at:

64 Airborne
33 Army
25 Rangers
1 57mm ATG
1 75mm pack howitzer
2 M3 Halftracks
2 Jeeps
1 M5 Stuart
3 M4A4 Sherman
1 M4A3E2 Jumbo Sherman
1 M10 Wolverine
2 M8/M20 Armored Cars
1 Bolt Action 2nd Edition book


And don't forget, today is your last chance to be in the draw for the Minairons Miniatures Henschel truck give-away! Support us before midnight and you'll be automatically entered into the draw.

Review - Butlers' Printed Models Jeeps

Butlers' Printed Models offers an interesting service - 3D-printed vehicles in different scales and covering WW2, Cold War and Modern vehicles, including several models I haven't seen anywhere else.
Today we will look at their first contribution to our project, which is the humble jeep, or rather, two jeeps!


This is a first for me, I have never had the opportunity to examine a 3D-printed vehicle up close. I have seen plenty of pictures, and like to pretend I know a thing or two about the technology, but I never actually got my hands on the products.

Many people will say that 3D-prints are still too rough and lack the details to compete with resin and plastic kits, and, well, that is true. Nevertheless, these jeeps are making a mighty fine impression on me:


The undersides are quite rough, but that doesn't really matter, does it?


There are some easy improvements one can make, i.e. taking out the printed windows from the frames and replacing the steering wheel. I hope to find a driver for each, and I'll add some of the surplus storage from other kits.

The stepping on the hood is quite obvious, but it is extremely easy to fix.


It took me literally less than two minutes to file it down to this, and some sanding should easily finish the job.

The size of the vehicles looks spot on:


I'll do another 5 minutes of filing/sanding on each and than they are going into the painting pipeline. No doubt they will make great additions to the army!

Review - JTFM/Die Waffenkammer Jumbo Sherman

Today we are going to have a look at the first donation from JTFM/Die Waffenkammer: A Jumbo Sherman, or officially, the M4A3E2 Assault Tank. This is a late war variant with additional armor and the powerful 76mm main gun.
Although only 254 of these tanks were built, they became quite iconic for the late war armored forces in Europe. For example, "Cobra King" of First in Bastogne-fame was a Jumbo.

All JTFM/Die Waffenkammer models come in stable cardboard boxes and the parts are wrapped in foam. I own several of their vehicles for my British 8th Army and I never had any issues with damaged parts. The Jumbo has four main components, two tracks, hull and turret:


In addition to all the small bits like hatches the kit contains a vast amount of extras: two crew members, baggage, sand bags, track links and bogey wheels:


All of these pieces are of outstanding quality - in my humble opinion JTFM/Die Waffenkammer is a strong contestant for the best resin models on the market!


Assembly is easy - the hardest part is to decide which of the optional bits you want to on your model. I use two-component glue for resin models, and as far as i can tell it will never come apart again.

Here are some pictures of the finished model:


That brings our army up to:

64 Airborne
33 Army
25 Rangers
1 57mm ATG
1 75mm pack howitzer
2 M3 Halftracks
1 M5 Stuart
1 M4A4 Sherman

1 M4A3E2 Jumbo Sherman
1 M10 Wolverine
2 M8/M20 Armored Cars
1 Bolt Action 2nd Edition book

If you are really paying attention to our project you'll have noticed a new sponsor on the list - we will have a look at their contribution next.

And keep in mind that there is still time to enter our bonus give-away of the Henschel truck - see below for all details!